• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Poor Gary's Pizza

At Poor Gary's Pizza, nestled in the heart of Moose Lake, MN, a passion for delicious food and friendly service shines through. Established with a commitment to exceptional quality, Poor Gary's serves up a diverse menu featuring mouthwatering pizzas, savory pastas, and crisp salads, all crafted with care. Patrons rave about the taco pizza and the classic spaghetti & meatballs, showcasing a blend of flavors that leave lasting impressions. The inviting atmosphere encourages community connection and memorable meals, making it a must-visit spot for locals and visitors alike. Experience the warmth of Poor Gary's—where every bite tells a story.

LOCATIONS

Welcome to the delicious world of Poor Gary's Pizza, where every slice tells a story. Nestled in the heart of Moose Lake, MN, at 401 Elm Ave, Poor Gary's Pizza is more than just a pizzeria – it’s a beloved community spot that fans rave about. With a phone number of (218) 485-8020, it's easy to call in your order or perhaps inquire about their tantalizing menu options.

What sets Poor Gary's apart? Let’s delve into their specialties.

  • Pizza: The star of the show! Customers have declared it as the "BEST PIZZA EVER." With a variety of toppings and styles, it's clear why people keep coming back for more.
  • Salads: Options like the House Salad ($7.00), Chef Salad ($11.00), and Taco Salad ($11.00) provide a refreshing complement to the hearty pizzas.
  • Appetizers: Don’t skip the delicious Garlic Cheese Bread to warm up your meal.
  • Pastas: Indulge in savory spaghetti & meatballs ($12.00) or the creamy Chicken or Shrimp Alfredo ($14.00) for a delightful change from pizza.

When it comes to service, diners have noted the fast and friendly staff, even during busy hours. While occasional order mix-ups have happened, the sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive. As one customer, Jason D., aptly put it, Poor Gary's delivers "pizza that kicks ass!" This enthusiastic endorsement reflects the genuine love patrons have for the food.

Moreover, the ambience at Poor Gary’s is lively and welcoming. It’s connected to a pub, making it an ideal spot for hanging out with friends or family. One enthusiastic patron, Gina B., described a vibrant atmosphere filled with laughter and great food, proving that Poor Gary's is not just a place to eat but a destination to create memories.

Those who indulge in the taco pizza or the classic sausage and cheese come back time and again, proving that variety in flavor is part of the charm. As Heidi S. shared, her two visits yielded equally satisfying experiences, showcasing the restaurant’s consistent quality.

Whether you’re dining in or utilizing their efficient delivery service, Poor Gary's Pizza is a culinary gem worth discovering. With their tantalizing offerings and a warm-hearted staff ready to serve, it’s no wonder this establishment has carved out a special place in the hearts of locals and visitors alike. So the next time you're in Moose Lake, don’t miss the chance to experience what Poor Gary's is all about!

START YOUR REVIEW OF Poor Gary's Pizza
Jason D.
Jason D.

Poor garysbin Eveleth mixed up my order. Gave me the mix up and the new one. Pizza kix ass. The place to go since Dave's sux.

Aaron V.
Aaron V.

Great pizza, fast service and always friendly. Sometimes you do have to call a few times when they are busy.

Gina B.
Gina B.

BEST PIZZA EVER!!!!!!! OMG! No idea what Jacob H. was talking about, he was probably the idiot who got in a fight & punched an old dude on Sunday when we were there. There were 12 of us, 8 ordered pizza, the rest ordered apps & everything was amazing! Came out fast & hot, workers were super busy but did an amazing job! It is connected to a pub where the fight was but that was also handled right away & I swear they called him Jacob before kicking him out.....Jacob needs to grow up & get a life, Poor Gary's is definitely someplace I'm coming back to!

Heidi S.
Heidi S.

We had pizza here twice while staying in Biwabik. First night we had the taco pizza which was fantastic. 2nd night we just had sausage and cheese. Equally as good! We will definitely order again next time we are in the area.

Edie C.
Edie C.

Always good food and pizza. We eat in and they also have delivery service. Nice folks, good service. A must try in Biwabik

Kaila F.
Kaila F.

Food was amazing. We had a big table, so it took a bit but I expect that for a small bar. I had the crispy chicken sandwich, and I will be back to have it again.

Amanda F.
Amanda F.

I order pizza from Poor Gary's a lot. Delivery is usually 45 minuted 4 miles away and the people are nice and courteous. X-large pizza for us is $22 and change. Always tastes awesome reheated too!!